DateOpponentVenueFixtureScoreScorers Attendance
06 Mar 1920Rotherham CountyHomeLeague1-2S Tonner 12,000
13 Mar 1920Rotherham CountyAwayLeague1-3S Tonner 7,000
20 Nov 1920Rotherham CountyHomeLeague2-0Warboys, Cockle 17,000
27 Nov 1920Rotherham CountyAwayLeague0-0 12,000
19 Nov 1921Rotherham CountyHomeLeague1-2Galbraith 12,000
26 Nov 1921Rotherham CountyAwayLeague0-2 9,000
30 Dec 1922Rotherham CountyHomeLeague5-1J Tonner (3), Bailey, O Williams 17,000
06 Jan 1923Rotherham CountyAwayLeague0-0 10,300
17 Nov 1956Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-1Sexton, Johnston 16,429
30 Mar 1957Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-2 8,049
25 Dec 1957Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague6-2Woosnam, Johnston (4), Hartburn 13,956
26 Dec 1957Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague2-2White, Johnston 10,935
11 Oct 1958Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-1Andrews 6,730
28 Mar 1959Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-0Baily, Brown 11,860
12 Sep 1959Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-3Johnston (2) 14,027
23 Jan 1960Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-1Biggs 16,131
01 Oct 1960Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Facey 7,338
20 Feb 1961Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-1Lambert (og), Lewis (pen) 9,613
21 Oct 1961Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Graham 10,581
09 Mar 1962Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Lucas 10,847
30 Nov 1963Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague4-1Dunmore, Musgrove (2), Ward 6,526
11 Apr 1964Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague0-2 7,455
19 Sep 1964Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-1Philips (2) 8,888
06 Apr 1965Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-3 6,514
24 Aug 1965Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Flatt 7,447
30 Aug 1965Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-4Scott 7,172
10 Aug 1968Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague3-3Halom, Jones, Brabrook 7,979
01 Mar 1969Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-3Rofe 6,850
06 Sep 1969Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-0 6,810
20 Dec 1969Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Brabrook 4,593
05 Dec 1981Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-1 6,346
01 May 1982Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-2Godfrey 3,009
17 Sep 1983Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-0Godfrey 5,518
22 Jan 1984Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-1Brooks, Houchen (pen) 2,204
24 Nov 1984Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Cunningham 3,932
20 Apr 1985Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague0-1 2,087
20 Sep 1988Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-4Ketteridge 4,289
04 Feb 1989Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague3-1Campbell (2), Comfort 3,290
17 Oct 1989Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague2-5Harvey, Cooper 5,728
24 Mar 1990Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Carter 3,359
22 Sep 1990Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague3-0Castle (2, 1 pen), Berry 3,492
05 Feb 1991Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-0 4,062
09 Mar 1993Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Bellamy 4,401
03 Apr 1993Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-1Taylor 3,235
09 Oct 1993Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Howard 4,304
22 Jan 1994Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2West 3,392
22 Oct 1994Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-2 2,702
07 Jan 1995Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague0-0 2,797
11 Oct 1997Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-1Griffiths 3,666
28 Feb 1998Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Griffiths 3,542
15 Aug 1998Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-4Smith 4,457
16 Jan 1999Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-3Watts 3,139
16 May 1999Rotherham UnitedHomePO sf-10-0 9,419
19 May 1999Rotherham UnitedAwayPO sf-20-0* 9,529
12 Nov 1999Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-0Ling 4,280
21 Mar 2000Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague0-1 3,959
23 Sep 2006Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague2-3Chambers, Miller 4,063
30 Dec 2006Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague2-2Chambers, Alexander 4,715
26 Oct 2013Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-0Lisbie 5,609
01 Feb 2014Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague1-2Odubajo 8,604
25 May 2014Rotherham UnitedWembley StadiumPO fn2-2+Odubajo, Cox 43,401
22 Oct 2024Rotherham UnitedHomeLeague1-0Happe 6,340
04 Mar 2025Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-1 8,106
18 Oct 2025Rotherham UnitedAwayLeague0-18,057
* Leyton Orient won 4-3 on penalties
+ Rotherham United won 4-3 on penalties