| 14 Oct 1905 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-2 | Codling | 6,200 |
| 17 Feb 1906 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-4 | Evenson | 3,000 |
| 10 Nov 1906 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-0 | Oliver | 5,700 |
| 16 Mar 1907 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-1 | Oliver, Martin | 3,000 |
| 30 Nov 1907 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-1 | Martin, Goffin | 6,200 |
| 28 Mar 1908 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-0 | | 5,000 |
| 07 Nov 1908 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-1 | | 5,000 |
| 13 Mar 1909 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-1 | Bell, Reason (pen) | 7,800 |
| 11 Sep 1909 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-2 | | 5,000 |
| 22 Jan 1910 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-0 | | 7,000 |
| 14 Oct 1911 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-0 | Bevan | 16,000 |
| 17 Feb 1912 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-2 | Bevan | 8,100 |
| 23 Nov 1912 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-1 | Scott, Parker | 5,000 |
| 29 Mar 1913 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-3 | McFadden | 7,000 |
| 20 Dec 1913 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-2 | | 6,000 |
| 25 Apr 1914 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-0 | | 10,666 |
| 07 Nov 1914 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-2 | Jonas | 7,500 |
| 13 Mar 1915 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-1 | Ridley, Parker | 6,900 |
| 03 Apr 1920 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 3-0 | J Tonner (2), Chapman | 10,000 |
| 10 Apr 1920 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-2 | | 5,000 |
| 04 Dec 1926 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-4 | Cock, Dennison | 11,859 |
| 23 Apr 1927 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-2 | Dennison, Corkindale | 10,033 |
| 27 Aug 1927 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-2 | Kerr, Dennison | 15,051 |
| 31 Dec 1927 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-2 | Holland | 8,738 |
| 15 Sep 1928 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-6 | Whipp | 10,280 |
| 04 Mar 1929 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 3-1 | Whipp, Corkindale, Turnbull | 5,209 |
| 13 Jan 1934 | Grimsby Town | Away | FAC r3 | 0-1 | | 13,500 |
| 08 Sep 1956 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-0 | | 18,251 |
| 12 Jan 1957 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-1 | Johnston | 16,406 |
| 24 Aug 1957 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-7 | Johnston (2) | 14,274 |
| 21 Dec 1957 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 5-1 | Johnston (3), Julians, Hartburn | 13,106 |
| 13 Dec 1958 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-1 | | 7,672 |
| 21 Apr 1959 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-4 | Johnston | 8,000 |
| 26 Dec 1963 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-1 | Deeley | 8,834 |
| 28 Dec 1963 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-0 | | 9,589 |
| 03 Dec 1966 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-1 | Holton, Price | 3,547 |
| 29 Apr 1967 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-1 | Whitehouse | 6,459 |
| 19 Aug 1967 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-0 | | 6,048 |
| 16 Dec 1967 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-0 | Simpson | 3,690 |
| 06 Sep 1980 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-0 | Moores, Bowles (pen) | 4,506 |
| 14 Feb 1981 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-2 | | 10,190 |
| 05 Sep 1981 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-2 | P Taylor | 3,764 |
| 09 Jan 1982 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-1 | Godfrey, Moores | 6,877 |
| 17 Dec 1988 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-2 | Juryeff, Comfort | 3,446 |
| 01 Apr 1989 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 5-0 | Harvey (2), Agnew (og), Comfort, Campbell | 4,149 |
| 23 Oct 1990 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-2 | Achampong, Carter | 6,660 |
| 27 Apr 1991 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-2 | | 4,302 |
| 14 Sep 1999 | Grimsby Town | Away | LC r2-1 | 1-4 | Lockwood (pen) | 2,238 |
| 21 Sep 1999 | Grimsby Town | Home | LC r2-2 | 1-0 | Watts | 1,036 |
| 18 Sep 2004 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 0-2 | | 5,082 |
| 15 Jan 2005 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-2 | Echanomi | 3,816 |
| 22 Oct 2005 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-0 | Easton | 4,963 |
| 17 Apr 2006 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-0 | | 6,582 |
| 20 Aug 2016 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-1 | Kelly, Palmer | 4,991 |
| 11 Mar 2017 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 0-3 | | 5,288 |
| 19 Oct 2019 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 4-0 | Happe, Coulson, Alabi, Wright (pen) | 4,132 |
| 11 Jan 2020 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 1-1 | Angol (pen) | 6,248 |
| 17 Oct 2020 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-3 | Wilkinson, Maguire-Drew | – |
| 02 Mar 2021 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 1-0 | Happe | – |
| 30 Jul 2022 | Grimsby Town | Home | League | 2-0 | Moncur (pen), James | 8,557 |
| 25 Feb 2023 | Grimsby Town | Away | League | 2-2 | Kelman, Moncur | 6,283 |