| Date | Opponent | Venue | Fixture | Score | Scorers | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Oct 1956 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 3-2 | Johnston, Heckman (2) | 22,481 |
| 09 Mar 1957 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-2 | Heckman | 17,731 |
| 14 Dec 1957 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 2-0 | Julians, Johnston | 14,715 |
| 26 Apr 1958 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 0-1 | 8,833 | |
| 18 Oct 1958 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Andrews | 13,562 |
| 07 Mar 1959 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 3-2 | Brown, Johnston (2) | 14,769 |
| 24 Oct 1959 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 2-0 | Foster, Johnston | 11,795 |
| 17 Mar 1960 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Facey (pen) | 7,084 |
| 03 Sep 1960 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-4 | Brown | 10,914 |
| 14 Jan 1961 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 1-4 | Elwood | 17,438 |
| 08 Dec 1962 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 2-2 | Graham, Dunmore | 9,874 |
| 26 Apr 1963 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 0-2 | 20,703 | |
| 15 Aug 1970 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 3-1 | Harper, Lazarus (2) | 10,584 |
| 17 Oct 1970 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 1-3 | Bullock | 20,205 |
| 20 Nov 1976 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 1-1 | Allen | 14,745 |
| 16 Apr 1977 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 0-2 | 7,697 | |
| 26 Dec 1977 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 0-2 | 18,370 | |
| 27 Mar 1978 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 3-1 | Kitchen (3, 1 pen) | 6,725 |
| 19 Aug 1978 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 2-1 | Mayo, Kitchen | 19,012 |
| 11 Nov 1978 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Kitchen (pen) | 5,540 |
| 01 Jan 1983 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 0-3 | 10,973 | |
| 14 May 1983 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 4-1 | Houchen, Kitchen, Godfrey, Roffey | 4,468 |
| 18 Oct 1983 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 2-0 | Godfrey, Houchen | 4,090 |
| 03 Mar 1984 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 3-6 | Silkman, Cornwell, Kitchen | 10,021 |
| 13 Jan 2009 | Sheffield United | Home | FAC r3 | 1-4 | Melligan (pen) | 4,527 |
| 22 Oct 2011 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Lisbie | 5,928 |
| 14 Apr 2012 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 1-3 | Lisbie | 18,272 |
| 06 Oct 2012 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 0-1 | 4,882 | |
| 26 Feb 2013 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 0-0 | 16,540 | |
| 30 Nov 2013 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Cox | 6,586 |
| 05 Apr 2014 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 1-1 | Cox | 16,809 |
| 23 Sep 2014 | Sheffield United | Home | LC r3 | 0-1 | 3,223 | |
| 11 Oct 2014 | Sheffield United | Away | League | 2-2 | Simpson, Vincelot | 19,179 |
| 25 Apr 2015 | Sheffield United | Home | League | 1-1 | Baudry | 7,249 |
| 06 Nov 2016 | Sheffield United | Away | FAC r1 | 0-6 | 6,099 |